Back in the Badia
Been travelin' round Jordan for the last five days, mainly in the northwest and in the Badia desert.
The Badia is Jordan's version of West Texas. I'm staying on an ecological restoration and social development project headquarters on a dilapidated air force base used by the Americans to stage bomber runs in the first Gulf War. Think Area 51 minus everything that makes Area 51 so cool (the X-Files, the video game, and the conspiracy theories) and that's been me for the last four days.
I did have the chance to hang with a semi-nomadic Bedouin family one afternoon and talk about the effects of rising fuel prices. For the Bedu, it breaks down into economic and cultural repercussions.
Shepherds and grazers have recently been experiencing negative returns on their flocks; it's costing them more money to raise sheep and goats than they are receiving at the market for them. The culprit? Rising fuel prices increase feed prices, as the accompanying increase in production costs are passed on to the consumer. You would think that they could absorb these costs by increasing the price per head of their animals, but with gas prices driving inflation across the economy on essential goods (for the same reasons feed prices are going up), the quantity demanded for goats and sheep, a luxury good for most people, is on the decline. The Bedouin find themselves caught between local market forces and global economic entanglement as their income decreases and their expenditures increase.
Next, they need water for the herds. Old school Bedouin could graze near natural water sources in the desert or rely on simple rain harvesting techniques. This has been made exceedingly difficult now due to increased water demand from the cities, which leads to over-pumping renewable groundwater sources (and in the case of the Azraq oasis, drying out the natural springs that once fed the wetlands completely); below-average rainfall (blamed on global climate change even out in BFE, where we saw some Al Gore light bulbs); desertification, caused in large part by over-grazing, which leads to increased surface evaporation and soil degradation; and changing hydrological systems due to diversion projects in Jordan, Syria, and Israel. Now, most of the Bedu have to live "on the grid" for water, which often means settling. If they don't settle they can drive into town to buy water (assuming they have a truck) from the government or private sector, but that's also too costly due to rising fuel prices and water scarcity, so it makes less and less sense, and in some cases it's completely unfeasible, to live away from the village and maintain the nomadic ideal.
To deal with these increased hardships, the government "encourages," rather than "pressures" (their words, not mine) the Bedu to settle in simple villages that provide basic social services. In some cases, shepherds and their families who have sold off all their animals live essentially on welfare with no income, as their only source of livelihood and only skill-set has became unsustainable. But method of subsistence isn't the only piece of culture is being eroded. Per customary Bedu hospitality, a sheep is slaughtered and served as a large family-style meal for guests. As you can imagine for the shepherds, that kind hospitality is more and more costly. Even for those who live in larger villages and moderate cities and maintain a sense of Bedouin heritage, buying a sheep for a special occasion or family affair is at the mercy of the increasingly expensive grocery list.
Who did the Bedu we talked to blame? Yep, America and it's control/persuasion (not sure which they meant) of the oil markets.
Regardless of whether oil prices are at their present levels due to speculation, sabre-rattling between Iran and Israel, or peak oil theory, the costs are felt in far more places than just at the American pump.



2 comments:
Insane.
Oh the joys of industrialization.
I still find it amusing how many people still associate the evils of capitalism with the image of the American population as a whole. I suppose this is a chicken/egg argument... but it still seems quite silly to gripe about an economical system by making personal attacks against a proliferator.
It seems oddly reminiscent of an old American saying that ALL commies EVERYWHERE are EVIL... haha. Oh the good ol' days...
Sure, I probably shouldn't be requiring a global economic/sociological perspective from nomadic people on the other side of the world... but Im an America, it is what I do. ;-)
Seriously though, it seems no surprise to me that we see such a tension between the practical merging of two very different economic, not to mention social models.
The question now is, other than dropping candy bars from airplanes... or wiring large amounts of cash to Swiss Bank Accounts of the homeless... what is the next great PR move for America... Because I think at this point, it is safe to assume we wont be changing our business policies any time soon.
You're very right about the tension between economic and social models. The Bedu have had a competitive, international market system (not to mention a few new national boundaries) introduced into a culture that historically has not bothered with such. It's interesting how the bureaucratic apparatus of the Ministry of the Interior tries to incorporate traditional positions of tribal leadership into their administrative structure, but even these are sort of a token symbolism rather than any sort of effectual politic.
It really is an unfortunate confluence of evolving geopoltical, economic, and environmental forces that are changing Bedu culture in ways that they themselves would deem "bad," not only because it doesn't look anything like their community's collective memory/heritage, but even practically speaking their kids have really no future to look forward to as either nomads or participating members in modern society.
Ironically, most of the development projects in the desert -- be them ecological, social, educational, etc. -- have some sort of connection to USAID in Jordan. Kind of ironic that the forces blamed locally for adverse inflation are the same ones that keep the Jordanian economy afloat, and in some cases are working to make it more sustainable and less pegged to oil.
Post a Comment